By Ben Smith:
Well, it wouldn’t’ be Thanksgiving week if I didn’t write about my disdain for the traditional meal, so here goes. In the past, I’ve usually resorted to writing about alternative recipes of an assortment of wild game in the place of turkey, but this year I want to do it a little different. The odds of any of you actually reading this and changing your menu for Thursday is pretty slim. And if you are willing to change your traditional meal based off of anything that I write, then I seriously pity your family.
So no, this year I’m not going to tell you what to cook. Instead, I’d like to talk about what was really at that first Thanksgiving feast. I obviously wasn’t there to witness it, but I have my suspicions that it wasn’t anything like what we were taught in elementary school. I could be wrong, but I doubt there were a bunch of families sitting around the table arguing over college football and trying their best not to bring up politics to keep from destroying one of two occasions where the family actually sits down together for a meal.
In fall of 1620, the Mayflower arrived in the New World. The first winter was incredibly harsh and many of settlers remained aboard the ship throughout the winter doing their best to survive. Over half of them would die before the following spring arrived. The arrival of spring and summer coincided with newfound relationships with natives that taught them how to plant and harvest crops. The first harvest was successful, and a celebratory feast ensued, one that would include members of the local Wampanoag tribe that played a pivotal role in the harvest.
This is what I want to focus on this week…the feast! Let me begin by saying that I’m a sucker for my mother in law’s pumpkin pie. It’s literally the greatest thing since sliced bread. However, our early settlers were not nearly as fortunate as I will be on Thursday as there were no desserts in that first festival. And yes, it was a full fledge three-day festival instead of just a lunch like we have now, another thing I think we need to get back to.
So, what about meats and veggies? Our contemporary Thanksgiving meal usually consists of a turkey, or ham, and a smorgasbord of vegetables and casseroles. Oddly enough, that first Thanksgiving feast mostly consisted of fish and shellfish. Edward Winslow, a colonist at Plymouth, kept a journal that detailed some of the foods served at the festival. He mentions bass, cod, lobster, and mussels in his writings. He also listed fowl as a meat that was consumed, and while that could be turkey, it’s more likely that it was duck, geese, and even pigeons.
Vegetables that were served at the festival were much closer to what we eat today. I mean, you can’t really change vegetables that much even over the course of four hundred years. Cabbage and carrots along with native plants such as peas, corn, and squash were on the menu. The one thing that I’d expected to go along with those, but didn’t, were potatoes. They didn’t really reach popularity in the New World until almost a century later. Sweet potatoes also weren’t grown in America until about twenty years after the first Thanksgiving feast. Another contemporary staple that early settlers missed out on. Fruits were also likely served in the form of plums, blueberries, grapes, and cranberries. However, due to the lack of sugar there was likely no cranberry sauce.
If you’ve made it this far through the column you might have noticed the main course hasn’t even been mentioned yet. The one absolute meat mentioned in any writings about the first Thanksgiving feast is venison. Winslow wrote that five deer were killed and brought before them by the natives. Did you read that? Five deer. How many of you entertain your Thanksgiving guests today with deer? If you don’t, then you should, lest you all be hypocrites!
Knowing that venison was the main course at this festival, I’ve recently found myself wondering how they prepared the meat. From what research I can find, it’s likely the deer was roasted on a spit over an open flame. Some of the meat was also used to make a stew. You’ve gotta wonder what type of seasoning they used on the meat, if any. I’ve cooked plenty of deer meat over an open flame, but none without some form of seasoning, usually Dale’s. You can put Dale’s on an old leather boot and make it taste good, but I doubt they had a bottle laying around in 1621.
I really don’t understand why venison isn’t a more popular Thanksgiving meal today than it is. For starters, it’s way better tasting than turkey and doesn’t make you sleepy after eating it Next, it’s definitely healthier. And last, it’s a lot more fun to come by than driving to your local Jitney Jungle and grabbing a frozen, farm raised thunder-chicken wrapped in plastic. One could argue, though, that watching your neighbor fry a not-entirely thawed out turkey is far more entertaining than grilling deer meat. Just be sure to keep your local fire department on stand-by.
Whatever your plans are for Thanksgiving, keep in mind why that first festival happened almost four hundred years ago. Those folks were celebrating being alive after enduring a year of loss and hardship. If we aren’t going to honor them by serving a similar meal on Thursday, the least we can do is honor them by being grateful for all of the blessings we are provided. Then we can honor them by going into the woods and killing a deer, which is exactly what I plan to do.


Leave a Reply